Chilling Facts About Indiana’s Abandoned Witches Castle

#5 The Murder Of Shanda Sharer Has Ties With The Property

On 11th January 1992, 12-year-old Shanda Sharer was gruesomely murdered by four teenage girls; Mistletoe Falls is said to have been a location related to the travesty.

The connection between the murder and the property prompted more public speculation of the Witches castle, causing the then owner, Darlene Roach, to be a victim of further vandalism.