Chilling Facts About Indiana’s Abandoned Witches Castle

#9 The Tale Of The Three Witches

This tale has stuck around roughly since the 1980s; though the lore hasn’t been officially substantialized, it has given birth to many urban legends about the property.

The story dates eons back to the alleged first settlers of Utica, who happened to be three witches. It has been said that the witches were ostracized by the public, resulting in their murders and burial in their cellar. Apparently, their spirits still wander around the property today.